Saving Money on Groceries

Why We’re Grocery Shopping on Amazon Fresh Now—And Why It’s Cheaper Than Wegmans

For years, Wegmans has been the gold standard of grocery shopping—pristine produce, top-notch bakery items, and an overall shopping experience that feels just a little more luxurious than your average supermarket. But lately, when it comes to filling up the fridge and pantry, there’s a new winner in town: Amazon Fresh.

Yes, the same company that delivers everything from books to electronics is now becoming the go-to spot for groceries. And here’s the kicker—it’s actually cheaper than Wegmans. Not just by a little, but in a way that makes a noticeable difference in your weekly food budget.

So what changed? Why are more people making the switch to Amazon Fresh? And is it really worth giving up that Sunday stroll through Wegmans? Let’s break it all down.

The Price Factor: Wegmans vs. Amazon Fresh

Wegmans has always been known for quality, but in recent years, their prices have steadily climbed. With inflation hitting everything from dairy to canned goods, even the most loyal Wegmans shoppers have started side-eyeing their receipts and wondering if they’re overpaying.

1. Grocery Costs Keep Rising at Wegmans

A quick comparison of staple grocery items tells the story:

Comparison Chart

For nearly every category, Amazon Fresh comes in cheaper—sometimes by a dollar or more per item. Over the course of a full grocery order, that adds up fast.

2. Amazon’s Deals and Discounts Beat Wegmans

Wegmans offers weekly sales, but Amazon Fresh takes it to another level. If you’re a Prime member, you get additional discounts on select grocery items, stacking on top of already lower base prices. Plus, Amazon Fresh frequently has buy-one-get-one deals, coupons, and digital promotions that make it even easier to cut costs.

For example, in a recent shop:

• Amazon Fresh had BOGO free deals on pantry staples like pasta and rice.

• Prime members got an extra 10% off fresh produce.

• They offered digital coupons on dairy and frozen foods—no clipping necessary.

At Wegmans, discounts are harder to come by. Yes, they have occasional sales, but you won’t see Prime-style perks that stack onto already-lower prices.

Convenience: Shopping Without Leaving the Couch

Another reason Wegmans is starting to lose its shine? The convenience factor.

Let’s face it—grocery shopping takes time. Even if you know exactly what you need, the process of driving to the store, navigating the aisles, checking out, and loading the car eats up an hour or more. And that’s assuming the store isn’t packed with weekend crowds.

With Amazon Fresh:

• Order in minutes. Add items to your cart from your phone or laptop and check out in seconds.

• Same-day or next-day delivery. Groceries arrive at your door without ever stepping foot in a store.

• No impulse buys. Ever go to Wegmans for “just a few things” and walk out with a cart full of extras? Amazon Fresh makes it easier to stick to your list.

For busy people—especially those balancing work, family, and everything else—this level of convenience is a game changer.

Quality: How Does Amazon Fresh Compare?

One of the biggest arguments for Wegmans has always been quality. But Amazon Fresh has seriously stepped up its game in the past few years.

1. Produce That Holds Up

Early on, people hesitated to order produce from Amazon Fresh, worried they’d get bruised bananas or wilted lettuce. But now, Amazon Fresh offers a guarantee on freshness. If anything arrives less than perfect, you get an instant refund.

Plus, their organic selection rivals Wegmans, from fresh berries to leafy greens to seasonal fruits.

2. Meat and Seafood Options

Wegmans still wins in specialty cuts of meat and seafood variety, but Amazon Fresh has affordable, high-quality proteins for everyday cooking. Their fresh salmon, grass-fed beef, and organic chicken match or beat Wegmans on both price and quality.

3. Name Brands & Store Brands

Amazon Fresh carries big-name brands like Annie’s, Kashi, Applegate, and Chobani—plus their own Amazon Fresh brand that competes with Wegmans' store brand.

And in a side-by-side taste test? Most people can’t tell the difference.

Hidden Savings: The Costs You Don’t Think About

Beyond just grocery prices, there are hidden savings that come with using Amazon Fresh instead of Wegmans.

1. Gas and Time Savings

Every trip to Wegmans means using gas, dealing with traffic, and carving out time from your day. If your nearest Wegmans isn’t close, those costs add up. With Amazon Fresh, your groceries come to you.

2. Less Food Waste

Shopping in-store often leads to buying things you don’t need, which can turn into food waste. When you’re shopping online, it’s easier to stick to what you need and avoid overbuying.

3. Subscription Perks

If you’re already a Prime member, you get free Amazon Fresh delivery, making it a no-brainer for anyone who shops regularly.

Should You Ditch Wegmans for Amazon Fresh?

Let’s be real—there’s something comforting about shopping at Wegmans. The warm lighting, the fresh bread smell, the carefully curated displays of artisan cheeses. But when it comes down to cost, convenience, and overall value, Amazon Fresh is hard to beat.

Wegmans is still great for specialty items, unique cheeses, or bakery splurges. But for weekly essentials—produce, dairy, pantry staples, and proteins—Amazon Fresh wins.

Final Verdict: Amazon Fresh is the better everyday choice.

✅ Lower prices than Wegmans on most staples
✅ No need to leave home—delivery straight to your door
✅ High-quality produce, meat, and pantry goods
✅ Discounts and Prime savings stack up fast
✅ Less impulse spending, more budget control

So, if you haven’t tried it yet, now might be the time to switch up your grocery routine. Your wallet—and your schedule—will thank you.